 |
by André Voisin
PART II
MINERAL BALANCES OF SOIL AND MINERAL BALANCES OF GRASS
CHAPTER 5
Potassium fertilizers have a profound effect on
the mineral balance of the grass

Soil and the mineral balances of the plant

That the mineral balances of the soil
influence the mineral balances of the plant is a
hackneyed statement. The subject has been widely studied in works
on soil science and plant physiology. Let it suffice here,
therefore, to study only those alterations in the mineral balance
of the soil which, resulting from the application of fertilizer,
may have a part to play in the occurrence of grass tetany.
The role of potassium fertilizers in grass
tetany is so important that the effect these may have on the
mineral composition of the grass will be examined first of all.

The plant gorges itself with fertilizer potassium

The monovalent cation K+ is absorbed and
accumulated by the plant cells much more rapidly and to a much
greater degree than bivalent ions such as calcium(Ca++) and
magnesium (Mg++).

Table 3: Selective ion absorption by plants
The plants listed in Table 3
were grown
in a solution containing equal proportions of the four ions sodium,
potassium, magnesium and calcium. This balance was greatly altered,
however, in the cells of the plant tissue, and the results
obtained show that in such common crop plants as maize or potatoes,
potassium is accumulated by the cells of the plant to a much greater
degree than the other ions, be they monovalent like sodium or
bivalent like calcium and magnesium. Another remarkable fact is that
in every case the cells of the roots tend to repel the sodium
ion, the concentration of which is much lower than in the nutrient
solution.
The result of this "avidity" of the plant cell
for potassium is that fertilizer potassium is absorbed very rapidly
and very heavily by grass, and not gradually and slowly like the
phosphoric acid of a superphosphate or the calcium of a marl. This
phenomenon is described as "luxury consumption" of potassium by the
plant.
All this means that the herbage's content of
potassium increases considerably and suddenly following the
application of potassium fertilizer, creating or accentuating
various mineral imbalances, as will be seen below.

Marked influence of potassium fertilizer on the mineral balance
of grass

Table 4 below
demonstrates the marked effect
of potassium fertilizer dressings on the mineral
balance 1
of two common grass species, cocksfoot and ryegrass. Such
dressings greatly increased the potassium content of the dry
matter while at the same time lowering the content of calcium
and magnesium.

Table 4: Effect of dressings of potassium fertilizers
on the mineral equilibrium of two grass species
The most marked effect of the potassium
fertilizer, however, was on the sodium in the grass, the content
of which became very low and sometimes even non-existent,
reducing in the case of cocksfoot from 0-91 to
0-04% (one-twentieth) and in the case of rye-grass
from 0-65 to 0-11% (one-sixth).
The mineral imbalances are particularly
obvious in cocksfoot which, as 'T HART points out, favours
tetany 2
much more than other grasses.3

Abnormal mineral ratios

A dressing of 2 cwt./acre [254 kg./ha.] potassium chloride
is equivalent to 1 cwt./acre [127 kg./ha.] K20. This is more
or less the quantity generally recommended for
pastures 4
or even less. Let us take as characteristic of the mineral balances
of grass the ratios:

|
|
|
| and
|
|
|
|
5
|
(in milli-equivalents) 6
|

It will be seen that a dressing of
2 cwt./acre [254 kg./ha.]
potassium chloride causes the sodium content of the dry matter of cocksfoot
to fall from 0-91 to 0-11%, that is, to an
eighth, 7
which is
considerable. The parallel increase in the potassium content, however,
raises the K/Na (weight ratio) from 1-70 to
40-10, 8
that is, multiplies it by
twenty. 9
At the same time the
ratio (in milli-equivalents) increases from 1-00 to
3-63, which means that it is multiplied by almost
four.10
When 4 cwt./acre [608 kg./ha.] potassium chloride are applied
the figures become even more abnormal, the sodium content becoming almost
nil (0·04%) and the K/Na ratio reaching the colossal figure
of 122-5.
The objection may be raised, and rightly, that a dressing of
this order is almost never applied in practice. But in the case of this
"short" experiment it was a case of one single dressing, and we
will see that as a result of the cumulative effects of
dressings of potassium fertilizers (or liquid manure) and, due
to the fact that the greater part of this potassium is returned via
the urine of the grazing animal, small dressings repeated over the
year produce more marked effects on the grass than one single heavy
dressing annually.

By favouring white clover, potassium fertilizer alters the mineral
balance of grass

The influence of potassium fertilizer on the composition of
grass can vary due to the fact that this fertilizer alters the flora of
the sward. The result is that, although potassium fertilizer always
increases the potassium content of the grass, it does not
necessarily reduce the latter's magnesium and calcium contents nor
necessarily increase its
ratio. In effect, potassium fertilizer favours the development of
white clover, the
ratio of which is lower than that of graminaceous plants (Table 20, Chapter
25) because its contents of calcium and magnesium are so obviously higher.
By favouring the white clover in the sward, therefore, the potassium
fertilizer applied can, in certain cases, increase the calcium and
magnesium contents of the grass relatively more than it increases
the potassium. The result in such cases is a lower
ratio of the grass.
By contrast, nitrogenous fertilizers generally tend to
depress white clover,11
with the result that the normal consequence of simultaneous potassium
and nitrogen dressings is a considerable increase in the
ratio of
grass and a slight diminution in its calcium and magnesium
contents.12
The different aspects of these mineral imbalances in grass
brought about by the application of potassium fertilizers will now be
dealt with in greater detail.
| Go to Chapter 6 |
| Grass Tetany Table of Contents |
| Home |
Ag. Library |
Health Library |
Sovereignty Library |
Notes
[Click on asterisk (*) at the end of a note to return
to the point you left in the text]
- Table 22 (Chapter 25) shows equally clearly the
mineral imbalances caused by potassium fertilizer application.
Cf. also Tables 4, 7, 13 and 18.
*
- See Table 24 (Chapter 28) regarding tetany
triggered off by the application of sulphate of ammonia to a
temporary pasture composed mainly of cocksfoot. This question of
the tetany-producing nature of cocksfoot will be dealt with
in discussing the influence of the flora on grass tetany (Chapter 30).
*
- In an ordinary pasture cocksfoot represents
only a small fraction of the flora and is a useful species from
many points of view. The danger is increased, however, if a
temporary pasture composed solely of cocksfoot is grazed. It was
a pasture of this nature that gave rise to the very serious
outbreak of tetany at the National College of
Agriculture, Grignon (France) in 1959.
*
- For the quantities of fertilizer generally recommended
for pastures, see Chapter 10. *
- For the influence of temperature and humidity on
this mineral ratio, see Chapter 34. *
- For the possible relationship between this ratio and
the incidence of tetany see Chapter 26 and Table 21. The opinion
is that when the
exceeds 1-80 the danger of
tetany is greatly increased, at least under certain defined conditions.
*
- It will be seen (Table 7, Chapter 8) that, depending on the
relative rates of potassium and sodium fertilizer application, the sodium
content of oats can vary from 0-04 to 1-79%,
or in the proportion of 1 to 45. *
- DE VUYST, in Belgium, has observed variations in
the K/Na ratio between 5-8 and 75-9, or
in the proportion of 1 to 13, for grass, in a single region.*
- The unfavourable consequences of this high K/Na ratio for
the functioning of the adrenal cortex will be discussed in Chapter 23: also
how this can favour tetany.*
- The effect of potassium dressings on other ratios or
differences such as basic surplus, base : acid ratio, etc., were
also studied. See B0SCH and VERDEYEN. *
- But this is not obligatory. See Part XIII "Effect
of nitrogenous fertilizers on grassland flora", pp. 213-40 of
my book Better Grassland Sward. *
- This question of white clover will be discussed again
in studying the influence of the flora on grass tetany (Chapter 30).
*
|
 |